00:00
00:00
Dunso

65 Movie Reviews w/ Response

All 278 Reviews

1 reviews is hidden due to your filters.

Charming. Good sound effects, and it had some cool camera work like the camera spinning a bit along with the chair. Humour was alright, but I feel the main draw is the nice and simple aesthetic.

PenguinPotential responds:

Thanks Dunso! Really appreciate the feedback. I'm working on my writing style currently, so hopefully the next animations will have tighter beats. I'm glad you liked the camera-work! <3

The absolute plebery of this having 2.5 is too much to bear. I'm impressed by the aesthetic and how elaborate it feels. It seems pretty random, but there's a real vibe going on like in all of your work.

horizon-hugger responds:

lol thank you! it's fairly random movements. just an experiment with audio modulated animation to practice effects.

What the fuck. Animators have gotten so good. In a word, satisfying.

kRyy responds:

You just gotta choose the right ones

It's been a long time since I heard music on NG so obviously recorded from a speaker with a phone/headset. You get half a point extra just for that.

MovieMaximum responds:

The thing is that i could have easily just downloaded that music from an website considering that its Kevin Macleod music. But i edited this at night and got so annoyed with this film that i just didn't even care anymore.

Not bad. The sort of overall theme is nothing too new, but nothing bad either. The animation is a little bit stiff, particularily the walking is not your strongest point.

Now to the good parts. Good length, not just a clip and not too dragged out either. Enemies to an extent react and try to defend themselves. There are some funny and interesting kills in here, such as stealing the magazine and knocking a guy out with it. It's not just a stream of grunts being gunned down in the same way, which I think is important. I haven't seen the fading blood effect you use before, and you used a nice effect for the teleportation in the end. You also add a good amount of props to each room.

In the end, if you keep practicing the animation will get better. After that get some self made sprites in there and come up with a unique setting and you're good.

Mark741 responds:

Thanks for the comment m8, walking is indeed not my strong pont (I mentioned in my earlier movies as well) anyway, i'll keep on practicing off course :)

fucking weeb

Gibb50 responds:

nani?!

Wow, I'm surprised to see so many old animators still going strong. Some names I haven't seen before doing a real good job too.

Average animation quality was HIGH!
Pretty good variety of settings and fighting styles, as far as madness goes. I think I saw a little good original art in there too.
The flags next to the names were a really cool adition, shows how diverse the madness community really is.
The video was lengthy but not too long.
The music was alright, just not my taste.

So yeah, this was pretty original as far as a collab goes. I've given collabs a lot of hate in the past, but this one is pretty nice. Good job guys.

GabrielBarsch responds:

thanks dunso <3

What really stood out as great to me here was the interesting angles. They just lift it to a completely other level, so great planning there. Really surprised me when the gangster leader (Yui?) spoke. This reminds me a lot of Excel Saga, with the use of strange little side characters, like the army of cops, settings and kind of hyper mood.

One thing though, just my own pet peeve, Japanese names pronounced in English are kind of painful.

Kel-chan responds:

originally I wasnt gonna use the names but then i decided to just because of the terrible dubs most animes have

That's a fun perspective, I liked how you conveyed that the gun is heavy as shit through the animation.

GabrielBarsch responds:

thanks, your reviews mean alot to me ya know, you're my friend since 2008

It was good, the icon made me think it was going to be worse but the movement is what makes it. The art is a little rough but it's wonderfully cartoony in the way stuff swings around and stuff, I think you know what I'm talking about. The concept has been done before but in this style I think it was better presented than a lot of other ones of the same kind.

Art made up for with movement.
Old concept with better execution.
Fitting music.

Overall pretty solid!

DrJuiceMan responds:

Thanks for the constructive review.And I definantly glad the movement was positive enough for you to forgive the art lol.I'll definantly take all of these into account. :)

Blurb forever

Age 28, Male

Train driver

Sweden

Joined on 3/21/08

Level:
19
Exp Points:
3,710 / 4,010
Exp Rank:
14,127
Vote Power:
6.07 votes
Art Scouts
1
Rank:
Scout
Global Rank:
39,199
Blams:
56
Saves:
178
B/P Bonus:
4%
Whistle:
Bronze
Trophies:
2
Medals:
344
Supporter:
5y 19d